The Liberal Apocalypse

Deep in the Bible Belt folks know the comfort of the coming Apocalypse.  Most have enough sense not to try to predict its exact date, but just about anyone can appreciate its appeal.  The End of Days is an escapist/revenge fantasy in which all those fools who doubted us will weep amid a variety of sadistic torments while we enjoy an everlasting snow day.

How many of us who were raised in the era before constant electronic communication remember the feeling of coming home to an empty house and wondering if The Rapture had occurred?  Come on, don’t be shy, go ahead and raise those hands…

In this age of equality, why should liberals miss out on the apocalyptic fun?  Turns out there’s a long secular history of apocalyptic thinking and it has produced policies just as toxic as anything dreamed up by fundamentalists.  Going all the way back to Thomas Malthus in the 18th Century people have been warning that our prosperity will be our undoing; that capitalism and growth will leave the world a scorched, lifeless heap.  They’re still wrong.

Now the normally rational Tom Friedman is ringing that bell in a New York Times piece.  He is embracing the work of doomist Paul Gilding and announcing that “The Earth is Full.”  Friedman and Gilding are a little late to this party.  Environmentalist Paul Ehrlich predicted population doomsday almost half a century ago.  So how are those predictions turning out?

Human populations, which the Malthusians in every age predict will overwhelm us any day now, not only failed to do so, they seem to be approaching a peak of around nine billion perhaps later this century.  One of China’s worst looming problems among a galaxy of looming problems is a potentially catastrophic population decline.  Everywhere in the world where free markets and economic vitality have triumphed population growth is slowing and in some cases beginning to reverse.

The Malthusians have been consistently wrong for more than 200 years – a worse record than Harold Camping, but we just can’t stop ourselves from buying what the doomists of every persuasion are selling. The population/environmental end of the world fills the same psychological gap for the left that fundamentalists address with their ever-imminent Apocalypse. They even use the same language and imagery. There’s a perverse voice inside that us that craves The End, regardless of our religion or politics.  We’ll create that narrative out of whatever spare parts we have to work with.

Civilization always feels fragile and unnatural, doomed to collapse.  Yet on it goes.  Challenges like terrorism, global warming, and water scarcity come up, but solutions are always found somewhere between the panicked alarmists and the militant deniers.  It is innovation that makes us human and it is innovation that keeps us alive.

We are some very clever monkeys.  It would be a mistake to bet against us.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: